The history of federal Indian law and policy is a history of the dehumanization of Indian peoples and people. Dehumanization involves treating or regarding other human beings, often an entire people or peoples, as not being fully human, or as being not quite human. With regard to American Indian nations and peoples, dehumanization has involved a refusal to regard or treat Indian peoples as fully human. Terms such as “savages,” “heathens,” “pagans,” “infidels,” “barbarous,” and “uncivilized” have been construed to mean “you’re not quite human (sub-human) because you’re not White/European, and not Christian.”

In “The Dehumanization of Man” (1983), Ashley Montagu quoted Erich Kahler as saying that “dehumanization” has “scarcely been studied methodically.” It is time to take such a study seriously. In her book “The Shock Doctrine” (2007), Naomi Klein said the message of “hostile interrogations” is “You are no one, you are who we want you to be.” She calls this the very “essence of dehumanization.” That said, what has been the main message of U.S. federal Indian law and policy? “As an Indian you’re nothing; you are who, and what, we want you to be.”

The nineteenth century slogan, “Kill the Indian, Save the Man” encapsulates this dehumanizing attitude and form of thought and behavior.

The dehumanization of our Indian peoples has been manifested in many ways. The countless massacres, the forced removals, the boarding schools that tore Indian children away from their extended families, communities and nations, the sterilizations of Indian women in IHS hospitals in the 1970s, the attack on our languages, on our spiritual and ceremonial traditions, on our sacred places. These are just a few examples of the ways in which we have been continuously dehumanized by the United States.

There are other examples: Having Navajo men work in radiation-laced uranium mines without proper ventilation, resulting in death from various forms of cancer; the dehumanizing refusal to recognize our nations as being like other human nations on earth; being classified as “wards” (deemed either childlike or incompetent) under the “guardianship” of the U.S. federal government.

Once we make the concept of dehumanization explicit, it is able to provide a powerful framework for critiquing U.S. Federal Indian law and policy. Indeed, when the point has been made, it then becomes possible to realize that dehumanization has become silently accepted and taken for granted in federal Indian law and policy. The long U.S. tradition of dehumanizing Indian nations has been interwoven into Indian law and policy where it goes undetected because of an appearance of normalcy. Rather than being normal, however, it is dehumanizing for one people’s existence to be defined and controlled by another people’s decisions.

Why weren’t Indian peoples considered to have human rights? Simple; they weren’t considered fully human. Upon reflection, dehumanization is what made the UN Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples imperative. Its adoption by the United Nations General Assembly on Sept. 13, 2007, was a long-awaited endorsement of the fundamental human rights of indigenous peoples. It was the result of decades of work to put an end to the dehumanization of indigenous nations and peoples globally. Passage of that document sends the message that because indigenous peoples are fully human we possess and have always possessed fundamental human rights, including the collective right of self-determination, despite centuries of being regarded and treated as not fully human.

An example of what I’m referring to is found in U.S. Department of Agriculture’s “Report of Irrigation Investigations in California,” published by the U.S. government printing office in 1901. In an essay entitled “A Study of Water Rights in the Los Angeles River, California” Edward M Boggs, began with the subheading, “Discovery and Colonization.”

Expounding on this topic, Boggs wrote in the following manner about the Indian peoples of California: “Nearly four centuries ago, when the adventurous explorers of the unknown Pacific Ocean, following the shores of California, touched at various points, they found the land inhabited by savages.”

Those societies that have engaged in the process of dehumanizing indigenous peoples have always attributed to themselves an innate superiority. They have privileged themselves over the indigenous peoples as a means of arrogating superior rights to themselves and as a means of acquiring indigenous lands, waters and sacred places, which the dominating society calls “its natural resources.”

In keeping with the tradition of Western Christendom, papal decrees and colonial royal charters of various kings, contained dehumanizing language and authorized acts of “discovery” and “possession.” For one people, on the basis of a pretended “discovery,” to claim to own the lands and waters where other human beings are already living, simply because those invaders have managed to travel to that place from some other part of the world, and because their religion justifies it, is an excellent example of the dehumanization of the original peoples.

In his book “Like A Loaded Weapon,” Robert Williams said that the U.S. Supreme Court needs to be confronted with the fact that the Marshall model of case law is predicated on regarding Indians “as a savage, lawless race of legal inferiors.” Perhaps, however, this is part of a larger thought. The model of U.S. case law Williams has in mind is evidence of an active framework and tradition of dehumanization disguised as “law.” One part of the remedy is a full recognition of our humanity and our fundamental human rights as indigenous peoples, inclusive of our nationhood.

Steven Newcomb, Shawnee/Lenape, is indigenous law research coordinator in the education department of the Sycuan Band of the Kumeyaay Nation in San Diego County, co-founder and co-director of the Indigenous Law Institute, and author of “Pagans in the Promise Land: Decoding the Doctrine of Christian Discovery” (Fulcrum Publishing, 2008).